DOCTYPE html PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD XHTML 1.0 Transitional//EN" "http://www.w3.org/TR/xhtml1/DTD/xhtml1-transitional.dtd">

Dispatches From Blogistan » Blog Archive » safire tries hard
Dispatches From Blogistan

home   |   about the book   |   about the author   |   email   |   rss   |   search

the book
Dispatches From Blogistan
by suzanne stefanac
peachpit/new riders
voices that matter series
shipping now
> amazon
> barnes & noble
from the book
> table of contents
 
> ch2 history of open discourse
 
> 10 blog design tips
 
> what is this long tail?
 
> trackback demystified
 
> blog ethics primer
 
> glossary
 
> resource hotlinks

interviews

> cory doctorow

> farai chideya

> bruce sterling

> denise caruso

> craig newmark

> jamais cascio

> laura lemay

> christian crumlish

> jon lebkowsky

safire tries hard

02.20.06 @ 03:15:19 pacific

capIn one of his On Language columns for the New York Times, William Safire attempts to do a light piece touching on some of the new words and phrases growing out of the blogging phenomenon. The article bears his usual erudite stamp, but sadly, he gets several things wrong.

The word ping is generally considered to be an acronym for Packet INternet Groper (52,100 Google hits), not Packet INternet Gopher (1290 Google hits), as Safire would have it. If he really wanted to have fun, Safire could have pointed out that ping is one of many backronyms, acronyms constructed from words that match the letters of a word already in use.

As for his definition of meme, surely Safire must be familiar with Richard Dawkins and his 1976 book, The Selfish Gene. In that seminal tome, Dawkins defines a meme as a cultural entity–a song, a phrase, or an idea, for instance–that humans replicate by passing from one to another. It’s a perfect term for describing the way trends ripple across blogdom and so it is, indeed, often used by bloggers. Here is Safire’s description:

“A meme is a type of online chain letter,” explains Teli Adlam, a glossarian at blogossary.com, “where bloggers answer questions designed to give a quick overview of the blogger’s personality.” The author is then supposed to tag — that is, to induce — other bloggers to participate by answering the same questions. Tag, as a noun, is a descriptive label applied to an individual post.

He’s almost right about tags, although tagging may be applied to online photographs, videos, and podcasts, as well as blog posts. In touching on tagging and the remarkably popular social bookmarking site, del.icio.us, Safire oddly write:

Many bloggers strive to make it onto the del.icio.us front page (otherwise known as being popular).” This has led to the verbal noun or gerund deliciousing.

Deliciousing? Really? I must not run in the right blogging circles because I’ve never heard the term. Safire admits he collected most of what he reports in the column while blegging, or begging bloggers for information. His reporting won’t do much to remedy the perception of blogging as a poor source of information, but perhaps he had a bit of fun. For more fun, may we suggest that he try the Wikipedia and a few Web searches next time around.




trackback

The trackback address for this entry is:
http://www.dispatchesfromblogistan.com/safire-tries-hard/trackback/

// Begin Comments & Trackbacks ?> // Begin Trackbacks ?> if ($comment->comment_type == "trackback" || $comment->comment_type == "pingback" || ereg("", $comment->comment_content) || ereg("", $comment->comment_content)) { ?> if (!$runonce) { $runonce = true; ?>

Listed below are links to other blogs that have commented on this entry via trackback.

    } ?>
  1. matthew
    02.22.06 @ 05:18:16 pacific

    Love this post!

    It out-Safires Safire. Well done.

  2. } ?> if ($comment->comment_type == "trackback" || $comment->comment_type == "pingback" || ereg("", $comment->comment_content) || ereg("", $comment->comment_content)) { ?> if (!$runonce) { $runonce = true; ?>

    Listed below are links to other blogs that have commented on this entry via trackback.

      } ?>
    1. 02.22.06 @ 04:22:45 pacific

      thanks! i’ve read safire religiously for years and mean him no disrespect. it’s new territory and we’re all getting up to speed.

    2. } ?> if ($runonce) { ?>

    } ?> // End Trackbacks ?> // Begin Comments ?>

    comments

      if ($comment->comment_type != "trackback" && $comment->comment_type != "pingback" && !ereg("", $comment->comment_content) && !ereg("", $comment->comment_content)) { ?>
    1. matthew says:

      Love this post!

      It out-Safires Safire. Well done.

    2. } ?> if ($comment->comment_type != "trackback" && $comment->comment_type != "pingback" && !ereg("", $comment->comment_content) && !ereg("", $comment->comment_content)) { ?>
    3. suzanne says:

      thanks! i’ve read safire religiously for years and mean him no disrespect. it’s new territory and we’re all getting up to speed.

    4. } ?>
    // End Comments ?>

    leave a reply

Thanks for responding. To protect against spam and malicious postings under false names, I request an email address as identification. I will never post your email address publically or use it for any purpose without your express permission. If you'd like to include a URL with your response, it will appear with your comment.